Debunking Common Myths about ESG

Common myths about ESG

In recent years, the concept of Environmental, Social, and Governance (ESG) investing has gained tremendous attention in the corporate world and from U.S. politicians. Despite its growing prominence, various common myths about ESG have emerged. Let’s delve deeper to uncover the truth behind ESG.

Common Myths About ESG #1: ESG Is "Woke" Politics
Common myths about ESG

This is probably the most prominent of the common myths about ESG, particularly in the USA where partisanship has divided people over ESG. And it is wrong. ESG investing methods generally focus on non-traditional material risks to investments. That means that in addition to assessing financial risks, analysts also assess environmental, social and governance risks to a company’s long-term value and profitability. Sometimes ESG investing also looks for positive impacts and opportunities. Clean energy is a popular example of an investing opportunity with a positive environmental impact.


The intention with ESG is to create long-term value for businesses by considering environmental and social risks and impact, and ethical corporate governance practices. It’s more about responsible business practices than aligning with a particular social or political ideology. While some aspects of ESG may align with certain government policies, such as investing in renewable energy, the framework itself is about responsible business conduct and long-term value creation and risk mitigation. When done right, it must transcend political affiliations in favor of the fiduciary interests of investors.



Myth 2: ESG Solves Environmental Concerns


Not necessarily. Many ESG investing products focus more on risk mitigation to businesses than positive impact of businesses. The European Union has started to crack down on misleading sustainability and green claims, but it is still the responsibility of every investor to do their own research and read the fine print to be sure that they are getting what they want.


In addition, while the “E” in ESG stands for Environmental, the ESG framework encompasses a broader spectrum. ESG factors also address social aspects of the ways businesses are run, such as employee terms and conditions, human rights, and diversity, equity and inclusion. Governance factors encompass areas such as corporate transparency, ethical practices, and corporate board quality and alignment of stakeholder interests. ESG is seen as part of a comprehensive approach aiming for sustainable and responsible investment risk mitigation and long-term value creation.


However, some would argue that ESG should focus primarily on sustainability and climate change. New global voluntary disclosure standards from the International Sustainability Standards Board (ISSB) have dropped reference to many aspects of ESG in favor of climate-related criteria proposed by the Task Force on Climate-Related Financial Disclosures (TCFD). They have received strong support from regulators around the world, who understand climate change to pose a significant long-term threat to, and opportunity for economies and stock markets.



Common Myths about ESG #3: ESG is Only for “Green” Companies


Another common myth about ESG is that ESG considerations are solely for environmentally focused companies. In reality, ESG principles are applicable across industries. From tech giants to car makers to financial institutions, integrating ESG factors into business strategies has become popular for show-casing long-term viability, risk management, and building stakeholder trust.


What is more, there are many ESG products that offer diversification and “best in class” approaches to ESG investing. This means that asset managers do not rule out carbon intensive industries and companies from investments. Instead, they include in their “investible universe” the top performing companies in all sectors according to standard ESG criteria.



Myth 4: Pursuing ESG Hurts Financial Returns


There is academic evidence that companies implementing strong ESG practices often outperform their counterparts in various financial metrics over the long-term. Studies have indicated a correlation between robust ESG performance and better financial results over time, especially the quality of corporate governance and risk management. 


However, while global ESG investing was booming in 2020 and 2021, ESG investments have had a difficult two years in 2022 and 2023, with net outflows in five consecutive quarters according to a Reuters report. In part, this reflects wider economic trends. However, new European regulations that will crack-down on greenwashing in financial products, and U.S. Republican political attacks on ESG, have caused jitters among U.S. investors and asset managers who must remain focused on delivering returns to investors without being drawn into partisan fights.



Common Myths about ESG #5: ESG Reporting is Just a Box-ticking Exercise


Some skeptics view ESG reporting as a mere compliance requirement or a PR tactic. However, authentic ESG integration involves genuine commitment and strategic alignment with a company’s core values. It goes beyond surface-level reporting and necessitates meaningful actions and accountability throughout the organization.


A good way to tell the difference is that a more serious company is likely to publish tangible metrics and progress reports.


On this path, improving sustainability is now a major trend in many major corporations. Consumer and investor expectations are pulling companies towards setting targets for reducing waste, phasing out single-use plastics, and lowering carbon emissions.



Myth 6: Small Companies Can’t Do ESG


On the contrary, small and medium sized enterprises and start-ups have an opportunity to differentiate themselves from the big companies through adopting more sustainable and ethical business practices in the first place. Initiatives like responsible sourcing, waste reduction, employee well-being programs, and efficient resource management can be built into the business model from the start, they can be tailored to fit smaller budgets, and still have a substantial impact.



**The Reality: ESG can be an Opportunity**


ESG isn’t a passing trend; it’s a shift towards sustainable, responsible business practices, particularly on the sustainability and climate change front. Embracing ESG principles, or whatever it is people feel most comfortable to call them (sustainability, innovation, responsible investing…) offers companies a competitive edge, fosters innovation, and builds stronger relationships of trust and reputation with stakeholders.


We hope you enjoyed our myth busting and found it helpful. If you’d like to learn more, why not read our ESG for Beginners or take our ESG Quiz to delve deeper into your personal philosophy.

Tags :
ESG Basics,ESG Investing,ESG metrics,ESG Strategies,ISSB
Share This :

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *